Please select your home edition
Pantaenius FBW Comprehensive 728x90

New report explores ecological, economic effects of oyster reef restoration

by NOAA Fisheries 16 Jun 15:45 UTC
A restored oyster reef in the Little Choptank River, Maryland, supports many other species. © Oyster Recovery Partnership

Oysters play critical roles in the Chesapeake Bay ecosystem—by filtering water as they feed and by providing habitat and forage for other Bay species. But only about one percent of the historic oyster population remains in Maryland due to overharvesting, habitat loss, and disease. So partners including NOAA are working to restore oyster reefs.

By restoring these reefs—and the functions they provide—what changes can commercial fishermen anticipate? And what do restored reefs mean for the economy in the region?

NOAA Fisheries' Office of Habitat Conservation developed a technical memorandum, "Estimating Ecological Benefits and Socio-Economic Impacts from Oyster Reef Restoration in the Choptank River Complex, Chesapeake Bay" (PDF, 78 pages). It includes findings from scientists and economists at six different institutions.

The research was made possible by funding from the NOAA Chesapeake Bay Office and the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation. Using computer modeling, researchers focused on the Choptank River system. The system includes three tributaries where large-scale oyster restoration is under way: Harris Creek, Little Choptank River, and Tred Avon River.

Benefits from restoration

Researchers found that a "mature oyster reef" scenario (roughly 15 years after restoration) could support about 45 percent more (in biomass) commercially harvested fish and crabs than are harvested under today's "young oyster reef" scenario. They also looked at what happens when additional filter feeders that live on and near oyster reefs (such as anemones, barnacles, hooked mussels, and tunicates) are added into the mature oyster reef scenario. In that case, blue crab harvest in the Choptank River system could increase 80 percent relative to the current scenario—that's 2.4 million pounds of crabs. Blue crabs would increase primarily because the food they prefer is often found in and around oyster reefs.

Having additional commercially important fish and crabs in the water could benefit the regional economy. The researchers used the IMPLAN (impact analysis for planning) economic impact computer model. It determined that for every dollar generated through increased dockside sales of harvested fish, there is an economic multiplier effect. That means an additional $1.07 in economic activity is generated in the form of employee wages, repair and maintenance expenditures at marinas, gear and bait, and the like. Models indicate that the scenario with mature (and therefore healthier) reefs with filter feeders could support 142 additional full and part-time jobs in the Choptank area. It could also enable an additional $9.9 million in total sales.

Researchers used Ecopath with Ecosim, a computer model that works with ecosystems and food webs, to explore how the food web would be affected based on a handful of different scenarios. For example, reefs in the Choptank River system are currently considered by the researchers to be "young reefs." Restoration there was completed in 2015 in Harris Creek and is still under way in the Little Choptank and Tred Avon rivers. How would having mature oyster reefs (roughly 15 years after restoration) affect the number of blue crabs? Or what would happen to the blue crab population if the sanctuaries were opened to oyster harvest?

The model simulations described how the different scenarios would affect the ecology of the area—supporting more or less fish and crabs. Researchers then used those results to look at how different population levels would affect how much fish and crabs would be harvested from the waters. They also looked at how that would affect the local economy.

The study is geographically focused; conditions in other parts of the Chesapeake Bay (salinity, temperature, turbidity, levels of fishing effort, and other parameters) are different. Results in this study cannot necessarily be transferred to other parts of the Bay. But now that the models and methods have been established data from other systems could be utilized to explore ecological and economic outcomes.

More details, including a look at each of the five scenarios the researchers explored and a significant amount of data, graphs, and charts, are available in the Technical Memorandum.

Related Articles

Black sea bass sensitive to ocean noise
Scientists gave black sea bass a hearing test Scientists looking at the effects of underwater pile driving and construction noise on sea life have found that black sea bass can hear these sounds. The noise may interfere with their natural behavior. Posted on 1 Nov
Climate change impacts on economic fish species
New project to understand how climate change might influence commercially important fish stocks Researchers at NOAA's Southeast Fisheries Science Center and Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory are teaming up. They want to understand how changing ocean conditions might be influencing commercially important fish stocks. Posted on 30 Oct
Video: How do you shuck an oyster?
Demonstrating the Chesapeake stab method John Paul Sebatier and Johnny of Rappahannock Oyster Bar in Washington D.C. demonstrate the Chesapeake stab method of shucking oysters. Posted on 25 Oct
Sports medicine leads to discovery about mussels
Feeding rates of blue mussels slow down under ocean acidification conditions Shannon Meseck, a NOAA Fisheries research chemist and marathon runner, was initially interested in how ultra-runners can tolerate higher levels of carbon dioxide than non-athletes. Posted on 6 Oct
The impacts of ghost nets on coral reefs
Researchers use structure from motion photogrammetry to measure the damage Ghost nets are silently drifting through the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands, snagging on coral reefs and entangling wildlife. Posted on 5 Oct
Top five shark videos and more
A closer look at how we conserve and study these top ocean predators This Shark Week, check out our shark features and top five shark videos to get a closer look at how we conserve and study these top ocean predators. Sharks play an important role in the food web, helping to ensure balance in the ocean's ecosystem. Posted on 17 Aug
Genetic evidence points to critical role of skates
Skates are an important predator and widely distributed across Alaska marine ecosystems Skates are an important predator and widely distributed across Alaska marine ecosystems. There is interest in developing commercial fisheries for them. Posted on 16 Aug
Are all U.S. sharks overfished?
Majority of sharks harvested in the U.S. are species with above-target population levels The world's oceans are home to around 500 species of sharks. With so many species, it's difficult to talk about the status of shark stocks overall. Posted on 15 Aug
Ocean heat waves dramatically shift habitats
"Thermal displacement" reflects how far species must go to follow preferred temperatures Marine heat waves across the world's oceans can displace habitat for sea turtles, whales, and other marine life by 10s to thousands of kilometers. Posted on 14 Aug
Illustrating the need for essential fish habitat
A new outreach tool in Hawaii bridges science and art NOAA Fisheries recently developed an innovative scientific illustration that shows how various habitat features support different life stages of a fish—uku, or grey snapper (Aprion virescens), in this example. Posted on 9 Aug
38 South - Merry Fisher 795 Series - FOOTERMarina Exchange FOOTER 1