Please select your home edition
Pantaenius FBW Comprehensive 728x90

Unlawful search - Part 2

by Peter A. Janssen 14 May 2018 14:31 UTC
Can local officials stop and search your boat, even if they have no reason to think you've done anything wrong? © Peter A. Janssen

Last week we wrote about Frederick Karash, 37, of North East, Pennsylvania, who was fishing with four friends on his 23-foot boat in Lake Erie two years ago when he was stopped by an officer with the Pennsylvania Fish and Game Commission who checked to see everyone had fishing licenses. They did, but the officer then conducted a safety inspection of the boat and found only four life jackets for the five people. He issued Karash a citation with a $75 fine for the missing PFD.

Karash fought in the fine in court, saying the search of his boat was unconstitutional and violated his rights under the Fourth Amendment, which provides protection against unwarranted searches and requires authorities to have probable cause to search someone's home or property. Recently, a nine-judge panel of the state Superior Court heard the case, where Karash was represented by the ACLU.

After we published Karash's story last week, I received an email from Caroline Mitchell, the ACLU lawyer who argued his case. She also owns a sailboat in Erie, Pennsylvania, and she gave me permission to print her message:

"The ACLU considers this to be a very important case, because boats and boaters all over the country are being subjected to unconstitutional searches by local boating officials when there is absolutely no evidence of anything the boater is doing wrong to justify the stop and search.

"In Fred's case, his 23-foot cabin cruiser on Lake Erie was subjected to a stop-and-board for an hour, during which they 'tore through his things' and finally issued a citation for being 'short' one PFD. The Pennsylvania PFD law is 'mandatory presence, optional use.' We expect this case to end up in the Supreme Court. As a lifelong boater who has personally suffered through illegal stop and boards, that cannot happen soon enough."

She subsequently wrote me that she had been talking with friends in Florida "where suspicion-less stop-and-boards are routinely committed by Florida state boating officials with great inconvenience to many boaters trying to make a bridge or get into a port before dark.

"This was a big issue in Ohio, which recently passed a Boater Freedom Act to force boat officials to obey the Constitution. This is a national issue, not just a local one; 379,000 registered boaters in Pennsylvania are subject to random suspicion-less stop-and-board from state officials. Nothing prevents boaters from being stopped by different crews of officials on the same day. Stops often occur multiple times during the season.

"I've personally been stopped half a dozen times. They have never found anything on which to cite me, but I was delayed an hour on the Fourth of July weekend for a suspicion-less stop-and-board, while officials went through my boat stem to stern. They have absolutely NO suspicion to stop me, as I had current state registration decals and the U.S. Coast Guard current courtesy inspection. It was a most unpleasant interruption of my boating day."

In my own personal experience, I've been stopped many times on both coasts of the U.S. (and both coasts of Canada), most often by the Coast Guard but by local authorities too. In most cases the stops were professional and relatively brief, but some definitely were not.

So what do you think? Are local authorities only doing their job in conducting safety checks, even if they don't have any reason to stop and search a particular boat, or are they violating our Fourth Amendment rights?

Please write me at

Related Articles

Huckins starts new 38 Sportsman
With either outboard or hybrid diesel-electric power Huckins is starting work on its 38 Sportsman, and the 90-year-old company is offering its retro-styled cruiser with either outboard power or hybrid diesel-electric power, showing that it can still blend traditional styling with the most modern engines Posted on 3 Nov 2018
Stephens Waring designs new cruiser for C.W. Hood
New custom composite 57-foot cruiser for C.W. Hood Here's a first look at a new custom composite 57-foot Down East cruiser that Stephens Waring Yacht Design of Belfast, Maine, worked on for C. W. Hood Yachts of Marblehead, Massachusetts. Posted on 3 Nov 2018
Back Cove tests twin 300-hp Yamaha & 350-hp Suzuki
The Suzukis are 3 knots faster It's not often that you can compare the performance of a brand-new boat with different power configurations, but Back Cove has just released that information for its new 34O (for outboard) cruiser Posted on 10 Sep 2018
69 boats compete in Bass Harbor Lobster Boat Races
The lobster boat racing season is off to a good start The lobster boat racing season is off to a good start, with 69 boats competing in the eighth annual races all the way up in Bass Harbor, Maine. Wild, Wild West, a 28-foot West with a single 1,050-hp Isotta diesel Posted on 7 Jul 2018
Unlawful search - Part 3
Are these a violation of your Fourth Amendment Rights? We have written two stories now about the case of a Lake Erie boat owner whose 23-foot boat was searched by a Pennsylvania Fish and Game Commission officer who gave him a citation with a $75 fine for having only four life jackets for the five people Posted on 19 May 2018
New honors for Volvo's most-powerful-ever engine
Volvo Penta's new 1,000-hp D13 diesel engine Volvo Penta's new 1,000-hp D13 diesel engine, it's most powerful ever, and its IPS1350 pod drive propulsion system just won new honours from Boating Industry, the boating business magazine, which named them among the top boating products of the year. Posted on 5 May 2018
World's first robotic fish, to study life in ocean
SoFi, short for soft robotic fish, looks like a fish and swims like a fish Here's SoFi, the world's first robotic fish. SoFi, short for soft robotic fish, looks like a fish and swims like a fish, but it actually is the most versatile robot of its kind. Posted on 2 Apr 2018
New Hylas M44: Lots of light and classic looks
Hylas collaborated with the New Zealand builder Salthouse for new high-end, two-stateroom cruiser With its low profile, long straight sheer and more than a hint of clean, classic Down East lines, the new Hylas M44 was just introduced to the United States at the Palm Beach show. Posted on 31 Mar 2018
MJM introduce 53z with four 350-hp Mercury Verado
The largest outboard-powered express cruiser ever MJM is doubling down on outboard power, even on its largest yacht to date. Indeed, Bob Johnstone, the company's founder and CEO, just announced that they will launch a new 53Z, powered by four 350-hp Mercury Verados, in the summer of 2019. Posted on 30 Mar 2018
Hinckley building new 42-foot Sport Boats
A 63-mph Hinckley? Hinckley is on a roll. Last September it launched the first luxury all-electric, carbon-fiber 28-foot Dasher, named after hull number one of its iconic Picnic Boat, at the Newport Boat Show. Posted on 24 Mar 2018
Marina Exchange FOOTER 1