Please select your home edition
Edition
Pantaenius FBW Comprehensive 728x90

No universal right to paddle on most rivers in England and Wales

by Stillwater Trout Fisheries Association on 27 Sep 2013
Mark Lloyd, Chief Executive of the Angling Trust and Fish Legal Stillwater Trout Fisheries Association
The Chief Executive Officer of the Angling Trust and Fish Legal has written to the British Canoe Union demanding that it publicly accepts the established legal position that there is no universal right to paddle on most rivers in England and Wales, and to support the government policy of local voluntary access agreements.

The BCU has in recent months suggested on its web site and elsewhere that ancient laws might give people the right to paddle or row boats wherever and whenever they like.

Confusingly, the BCU is at the same time campaigning for a change in the law to allow free unlimited and unregulated access to all rivers at all times. The Angling Trust says it has also been reliably informed that the BCU has ordered its local staff and volunteers not to sign voluntary access agreements with angling clubs and landowners unless they allow access at all times.

According to the Angling Trust, this conduct by the BCU has coincided with a spate of widespread unlawful canoeing, increased conflict on riverbanks and threatening behaviour towards law-abiding anglers and their clubs over the past year. Anglers pay rent and a rod licence to go fishing, and are subject to close seasons and a wide range of bye laws, said the Trust.

The issue has been highlighted in a recent article published by the BBC, in which the BCU's suggestion of general public rights of navigation dating back to medieval times was explained as a 'misunderstanding' of the law by highly respected and independent barrister Jonathon Karas QC, an expert in this area of law. The BCU has responded to the article, hinting that it has conflicting legal advice. Lawyers at Fish Legal, which acts as the legal arm of the Angling Trust in England, have previously confronted the BCU with the established legal position, but have never been shown the BCU's advice.

Mark Lloyd, Chief Executive of the Angling Trust and Fish Legal, has now written to his counterpart at the BCU demanding that they reveal the conflicting advice, accept the law and work with anglers to promote voluntary access agreements so that paddlers and others can enjoy greater lawful access to rivers.

Mark Lloyd said: 'The BCU's position has now been independently referred to as a misunderstanding of the law, and I believe it would be irresponsible for them to risk greater confusion and conflict by denying that the law is anything other than clear: there are no general public rights of navigation above the tidal limit unless specifically acquired (usually by statute). They may not like the law, or the Government's policy, but as a national governing body they must accept both. The Angling Trust and its members are keen to increase access to waters for boats and swimmers where appropriate, but on a small island it makes sense to have agreements drawn up between local people to share access and to avoid conflict between users and potential damage to the environment.'
Protector - 660 x 82GAC Pindar Sailing NewsHella Marine - July 2016

Related Articles

Coast Guard medevacs injured fisherman near Martha’s Vineyard
A Coast Guard Air Station Cape Cod crew medevaced an injured fisherman Saturday afternoon from Muskeget Channel A Coast Guard Air Station Cape Cod crew medevaced an injured fisherman Saturday afternoon from Muskeget Channel between Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket. At around 1:30 p.m. the 75-foot fishing vessel Perception notified Coast Guard watchstanders that a crewmember had fallen and sustained injuries and was in need of medical attention.
Posted on 23 Jul
Marine Notice - Official Nautical Charts
Marine Notice draw attention to importance of using only official nautical charts to comply with flag State requirements This Marine Notice draws attention to the importance of using only official nautical charts to comply with flag State requirements, which implement the relevant regulations of Chapter V of the International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea (SOLAS), as amended.
Posted on 23 Jul
Marine Notice - VHF marine radios - Automatic channel switching
This Notice provides information on how VHF channel switching may interfere with safe operation of vessel communications This Marine Notice provides information on how automatic VHF channel switching may interfere with the safe operation of vessel communications.
Posted on 23 Jul
Wide Cleats make hardware upgrades easy
Retractable line cleats not only improve a boat's looks by eliminating bulky deck hardware, they represent a convenience Retractable line cleats not only improve a boat's looks by eliminating bulky deck hardware, they represent a convenience and safety upgrade by protecting against snagged fishing lines and stubbed toes. The 305 series Wide Line Cleats from Accon Marine are a simple upgrade to improve the appearance and appeal of a vessel.
Posted on 22 Jul
The four-year treasure hunt for the hoodwinker sunfish
Sunfish are famous for looking odd. They are the largest bony fish in the world, can grow to over 3 metres in length Sunfish are famous for looking odd. They are the largest bony fish in the world, can grow to over 3 metres in length, weigh up to 2 tonnes, and look a little bit like a suitcase with wings.
Posted on 22 Jul
Alvey fishing reel company to close after 100 years in business
Another Australian business has had to close its doors. Manufacturing is a tough business anywhere Another Australian business has had to close its doors. Manufacturing is a tough business anywhere, but in developed nations it is becoming an increasing challenging proposition. Building something for life is no longer profitable it would seem, with built-in obsolescence a key marketing strategy.
Posted on 22 Jul
Abandoned and derelict vessels in Florida and the Caribbean
Abandoned and derelict vessels (ADVs) are a marine debris problem in many places around the United States In this region, which boasts both beautiful weather and waters, a high number of recreational and commercial boaters unfortunately equals a high number of ADVs.
Posted on 21 Jul
Boating Industry reader survey reports Ethanol repairs increasing
A new survey by Boating Industry magazine says those in the boating industry are seeing a growing number of problems A new survey by Boating Industry magazine says those in the boating industry that manufacture, sell, repair and store recreational vessels are seeing a growing number of problems caused by ethanol-related fuels. Said one Minnesota boat dealer in the survey, “Ethanol fuels are great for our service department but bad for our customers!”
Posted on 21 Jul
Wet a line at the Sydney International Boat Show
No matter what research you do, it always points to the fact that more than half of all visitors attending the SIBS No matter what research you do, it always points to the fact that more than half of all visitors attending the Sydney International Boat Show have a primary interest in fishing.
Posted on 20 Jul
Safety first to build stronger fishing clubs
Sonya Kilkenny MP today presented Mornington Peninsula Fly Fishers club with a new defibrillator and first aid training Sonya Kilkenny MP today presented the Mornington Peninsula Fly Fishers club with a new defibrillator and first aid training as part of the new Defibrillators for Fishing Clubs program.
Posted on 18 Jul